Introduction
Cystic echinococcosis or hydatid disease, is a neglected zoonosis caused by the larval stage of the cestode
Echinococcus granulosus sensu lato (s.l.)(
1–
3). CE occurs worldwide with the highest incidence in the Mediterranean, eastern Europe, northern Africa, Central Asia, and South America. Molecular studies have identified several distinct strains within the
E. granulosis sensu lato (s.l.) complex that differ in their geographic distributions and host range (
4,
5). The pastoral life cycle of
E. granulosus sensu stricto (s.s.) typically involves dogs as definitive hosts and ruminant animals (eg, sheep, goats) as intermediate hosts (
2,
3). In Canada,
E. canadensis is the endemic species and wild canines (eg, wolves, foxes, coyotes) or domestic dogs, and moose, elk, reindeer or caribou may serve as definitive and intermediate hosts in the sylvatic life cycle, respectively (
6). Humans are accidental hosts, infected through ingestion of parasite eggs in food or water contaminated by dog feces (
2,
3,
6,
7). CE is an uncommon infection in Canada (
3,
6,
8) and rare in children (
9). However, with changes in the urban wildlife landscape—owing to human encroachment on natural habitats—and increasing global migration, CE may become more prevalent among children in Canada (
6,
10,
11). We report two cases in detail, a case of severe case of pulmonary CE in a child who had come to Canada as a refugee from the Middle East and the first locally acquired case of pulmonary CE diagnosed at our centre as illustrative cases highlighting the epidemiology, presentation, diagnosis, and management of this condition. We also identify four other cases seen over a 33.5-year period at the Hospital for Sick Children, a paediatric quaternary care centre in Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Methods
We performed a retrospective chart review of all paediatric patients (age <18 years) with a diagnosis of CE from January 1, 1988 to August 1, 2021 at the Hospital for Sick Children in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. Possible cases of CE were identified using International Classification of Disease (ICD) Ninth Edition codes [ICD-9 122.0 to 122.9] from January 1, 1988 to March 31, 2002, and ICD-10 codes B67.8, B67.9, and B71.9 from April 1, 2002 to August 1, 2021. Patients were included if they had: (1) compatible histopathologic findings, (2) positive serology with compatible clinical presentation, or (3) a clinical presentation, epidemiology, and imaging compatible with CE and were managed as such, but with no histopathologic or serologic evidence of CE. Medical records of children with CE were reviewed for the following parameters: demographics, symptoms, cyst features, serology, management, and outcomes. Ethics approval was obtained from our institutional research ethics board (REB# 1000043659) and consent for the highlighted case reports were obtained from the families.
Results
A total of 46 hospital records were identified using ICD-9 and -10 codes during the study period. Forty cases were excluded after medical charts were reviewed and were determined to have a diagnosis other than CE based on absence of epidemiologic risk factors, imaging findings, histopathology, and other microbiologic tests. Six children with CE were included in the study, with demographics of each outlined in
Table 1. The median age of the patients was 12.5 years (range 3–17 years) and there were four males and two females. All patients except for patient 2 were foreign born. The clinical presentation, diagnostic features, and management of each patient are outlined in
Table 2.
All six patients had CE based on histopathology, serology, and/or imaging. Four patients had hepatic disease and two had pulmonary disease. All patients except for patient 3 were symptomatic at the time of presentation. Patient 4 had been previously diagnosed with liver CE and was treated in Romania with radical surgery followed by a course of albendazole. While in Canada, this patient was non-adherent to albendazole therapy and re-presented to our institution. Given the patient's age, the patient was referred to an adult hospital for further management and no further clinical details are available for this study. All patients followed at our institution (five patients) required a surgical intervention (
Table 2). Four patients were treated with a combination of albendazole and praziquantel and two with albendazole monotherapy. Medical therapy duration ranged from 1 to 6 months.
Case 1
A healthy 12-year-old boy was referred to a tertiary care children's hospital after a chest radiograph (CXR) obtained in the community to investigate fever, drenching night sweats, and an 8-kg weight loss over 2 months revealed an unexpected finding of total and diffuse left hemi-thorax opacification. The child was seen in the emergency department where despite this impressive finding, he had no dyspnea, orthopnea, or hypoxia. At this hospital, a CT scan of the chest was completed revealing a large, 12 × 13 × 20 cm complex multi-cystic mass with associated near-complete left lung collapse, mediastinal shift, and prominent superior diaphragmatic lymph nodes (
Figure 1). Neck and abdominal CT completed at the same time as the CT chest to investigate for possible malignancy, were unremarkable. Given the concern for potential impact of the mass on cardiac output, an echocardiogram was completed, which was also unremarkable. MRI of the chest was subsequently performed showing again the multi-cystic left thoracic mass (
Figure 1).
A complete blood count revealed slight thrombocytosis (394 × 109/L, reference range: 130–380 × 109/L) but otherwise white blood cell count including eosinophil count was within normal limits. He had elevated C-reactive protein (94.4 mg/L, reference range: <10 mg/L) and erythrocyte sedimentation rate (70 mm/h, reference range: <30 mm/h). Serologic testing for E. granulosus IgG by enzyme immunoassay (EIA) was reactive with an index of 9.01 (reactive threshold >1.1).
In discussion with international clinicians with extensive experience in the management of complex cases of echinococcal disease, the decision was made to transfer him to the Hospital for Sick Children for surgical intervention. Empiric albendazole (15 mg/kg/d divided twice daily, maximum: 400 mg/dose) and praziquantel (25 mg/kg/d given once daily) were commenced 3 days prior to his procedure. The procedure consisted of a left anterolateral thoracotomy with catheter insertion through pleura into the mother cyst cavity, aspiration of cystic fluid, infusion of 3% normal saline into the cyst cavity, and re-aspiration of 1980 mL of fluid with minimal spillage. A subsequent total cystectomy of the mother cyst and lobectomy of the left lower lobe to remove two highly adherent smaller daughter cysts were performed. Microscopic examination of cyst membranes showed degenerating parasitic structures, while the cystic fluid showed hooklets consistent with CE.
The child was born in Syria and moved to Lebanon at 2 years of age before coming to Canada as a refugee when he was 8 years old, where he has remained ever since. The family lives in an urban centre in southern Quebec and have had no pets or other significant exposure to animals in Canada or elsewhere. The family was screened by their family doctor with CXR and abdominal ultrasound and were all subsequently negative.
The patient recovered well from his operation and was discharged home on postoperative day 15. He completed treatment for CE with 3 months of albendazole (15 mg/kg/d divided twice daily, maximum: 400 mg/dose) and praziquantel (25 mg/kg/d given once daily), followed by 3 months of albendazole monotherapy (15 mg/kg/d divided twice daily, maximum: 400 mg/dose), for a total treatment duration of 6 months. The patient remained well, regained the weight he lost, and returned to normal activities including sports. A follow-up CXR at the end of therapy was normal with good lung expansion, and a CT scan of the chest approximately 3 months after completion of medical treatment, 9 months after his surgical procedure, showed no evidence of disease recurrence in the lung parenchyma.
Case 2
A healthy Canadian-born 3-year-old girl was referred to the Hospital for Sick Children following an incidental finding of three round opacities in the left lung identified on CXR, during an admission for an uncomplicated ipsilateral pneumonia. Her pneumonia fully resolved after an appropriate course of antibiotics, however the cystic lesions remained unchanged on follow-up CXR several months later. She was otherwise asymptomatic and had no respiratory symptoms prior to admission.
Chest ultrasound and CT demonstrated three homogeneous, avascular, anechoic, fluid-filled cysts with smooth, well circumscribed walls, measuring up to 3.5 cm, in the left lower lung lobe (
Figure 2). Due to suspicion of CE, further imaging with abdominal ultrasound, echocardiogram, and whole-body MRI excluded extrapulmonary involvement. Blood work including eosinophil count was unremarkable and serologic testing for
E. granulosus IgG by enzyme immunoassay (EIA) was non-reactive.
After extensive discussion with infectious diseases, surgery, and paediatrics, empiric albendazole (15 mg/kg/d divided twice daily, maximum: 400 mg/dose) and praziquantel (25 mg/kg/d divided twice daily) were commenced 3 days prior to excisional total cystectomy, which was successfully conducted without fluid leakage. Microscopic examination showed that the cyst wall was comprised of inner germinal and outer laminated hyaline layers, and contained multiple protoscolices with hooklets and calcareous corpuscles, which were consistent with CE (
Figure 3).
The child has never traveled outside of Ontario, and lives with her family on a farm in a rural area of southern Ontario with several dogs, a sheep, and other farm animals. The family denied any history of hunting with dogs. Subsequent screening of other family members using CXR and abdominal ultrasound was negative. Due to the child’s diagnosis, household pets were also screened by stool examination, revealing echinococcosis affecting one dog. The patient completed treatment for CE with 6 weeks of albendazole (15 mg/kg/d divided twice daily, maximum: 400 mg/dose) and praziquantel (25 mg/kg/d divided twice daily), followed by albendazole monotherapy (15 mg/kg/d divided twice daily, maximum: 400 mg/dose) for a total of 4 months. The patient remained well and a follow-up CXR at the end of therapy was normal. A follow-up chest MRI approximately 18 months following completion of medical treatment showed no evidence of cysts in the lung parenchyma.
Discussion
CE is a rare but important infection to recognize as it can lead to significant morbidity and in some circumstances, death. CE causes tissue cysts, primarily in the liver followed by lung (
1,
2,
6). Many patients are initially infected in childhood but do not manifest symptoms until adulthood at which point a sufficient interval has elapsed to enable mass effect or compressive symptoms due to size (eg, biliary or bronchial obstruction, abdominal distension, headache). The latent period can last years to decades and mean cyst growth can be as slow as 0.7 cm over 10 years, therefore many are diagnosed incidentally (
12), particularly in children. Symptoms occur secondary to cystic complications such as rupture, compression of surrounding structures, hemorrhage, secondary bacterial infection, or organ failure. An anaphylactic and potentially fatal reaction following cyst leakage from minor trauma can occur (
9,
13).
Over a 33.5-year period at the Hospital for Sick Children, in Toronto, Ontario, Canada, six cases of CE were identified. Five out of six patients were above the age of 10 years. This is likely attributed to the long latency from primary infection to the onset of clinical symptoms (
12). While uncommon, CE can present in early childhood. In a retrospective review of CE in children in Turkey, only 5/152 patients were under the age of 5 (
14). One distinguishing feature of CE in children is the ratio of lung to liver involvement. Compared to adults, lung involvement is more common in children (
14–
16). Two patients in our case series had pulmonary involvement and only one was under the age of 5.
Diagnosis of CE in children is based on a combination of clinical presentation, appropriate epidemiological exposure, medical imaging suggestive of disease, serological markers, microscopy, and histopathology (1). In our case series, three out of the five patients with completed serologic assays had reactive tests. Sensitivity and specificity can vary depending on the type of assay used and clinical factors such as stage of cyst and cyst location (
17,
18). Until 2016, the Provincial Health Ontario Laboratory (PHOL) utilized complement fixation test (CFT) as initial screening, followed by confirmatory indirect hemagglutination (IHA). Both tests have poor sensitivity and specificity (
17,
18). In 2016, the PHOL replaced CFT and IHA with an immunoglobulin G (IgG) EIA. IgG EIA has an estimated sensitivity of 80%–90% for liver involvement, however, sensitivity decreases for lung (60%–85%) or other organ involvement (
17–
19). Unsurprisingly, patient 2 with pulmonary CE had negative IgG EIA. Patient age influences the reliability of serology, and often children with echinococcosis aged 3–15 years may have a nominal antibody response (
20). The reason for the difference in sensitivity between cyst sites is not well understood, but in part has been attributed to the higher immunological response to hepatic cysts compared to cysts at other anatomic sites (
21–
23). Cyst wall compromise through rupture or fissuring causes a robust antibody response, regardless of anatomic location, while calcified or senescent cysts less reliably generate an immunologic response (
24).
Treatment of paediatric CE depends on the size and location of the cysts, and if any complications are present (
1,
2). Management options that may be considered depending on location and staging of the cyst include observation, antihelminthic drugs (albendazole with or without praziquantel), surgery, and/or percutaneous procedures such as puncture, aspiration, injection of protoscolecide, and re-aspiration (PAIR) (
1,
25,
26). Albendazole is the primary chemotherapeutic agent for CE, however some observational data suggest that combined therapy with albendazole and praziquantel is superior to albendazole alone due to higher scolicidal and anti-cyst activity (
27,
28). For cysts located in the liver, treatment is guided by the World Health Organization diagnostic classification. Stage CE1 and CE3a cysts less than 5 cm in diameter can be managed with albendazole alone, whereas cysts larger than 5 cm require albendazole and PAIR. Stage CE2 and CE3b cysts require medical management in combination with a non-PAIR technique or surgery. Stage CE4 and CE5 cysts are inactive and can be managed by observation only (
1).
Five out of six patients in our case series were foreign born. However, with increasing changes in climate and animal migration, the geographic distribution of
E. granulosus sensu lato complex of species is likely to expand. Locally acquired human cases of
E. canadensis have been well documented in Arctic and sub-Arctic regions of Canada (
3,
6–
8,
29). However, patient 2 had CE despite having never left southern Ontario and is the first locally acquired case diagnosed at our institution in over three decades.
The retrospective collection of data from a single quaternary paediatric centre and the small number of cases identified are key limitations of this study. CE is an infection that is challenging to diagnose and requires a high index of suspicion, particularly in children and centres from non-endemic regions. The lack of a reliable gold standard diagnostic assay further compounds this diagnostic challenge and may result in incorrect ICD-coding and underdiagnosis. ICD-9 and 10 codes were key in case ascertainment for this study and as a result the true number of cases encountered at our centre may be underestimated by the study findings. This series also captures only those cases who were symptomatic enough from CE to seek medical care or were unwell due to another illness that prompted diagnostic imaging. For some patients, the management happened in other countries or institutions and those records were unavailable to us.
In conclusion, CE is an uncommon infection in Canadian children. Diagnosis can be challenging and relies on eliciting epidemiological exposures, appropriate imaging, and complimentary serologic testing. As the geographic distribution of E. canadensis moves further south in Canada, prompt recognition of this infection is important to prevent morbidity and mortality.